Tentative Story Concept -- Hannah of Eslohe's time among the Restitvtores Ecclesiae Verae of Rürenbourg

jecarv's avatar
female denial | fantasy | story | bi female | sub female | *occult | abstinence | bondage | chastity | discipline
This isn't really a story, so much as a sort of trial balloon. I'm wondering about the basic viability of the concept. Namely, is the idea 1) so boring that it should never see the light of day, 2) neat as a basic idea, but cut out the "letter" format and the stilted, fake medieval styling in favor of more normal style, or 3) a good idea, stilted fake medieval styling, letter-based format, and all.

Obviously, this has a lot more exposition and less action than the bulk of the story would have. The idea is more to introduce the sort of concept and atmosphere of the story than to go straight into the action.




A letter from Hannah of Eslohe, a nun of the Ordo Sanctae Clarae, to Heinrich II von Virneburg, Archbishop of Cologne, 1326

Anno Domini MCCCXXVI

Your Grace,

It is with the utmost reticence that I write you this letter, but having exhausted every other means of which I can conceive, I see no alternative but to beseach you for aid.

Several months ago, I was approached by an esteemed secret agent of the Holy Office. His identity will no doubt be clear to you, but I dare not write his true name openly in this letter, lest the secret spill out, reaching eyes other than yours or mine. This agent believed that the imperial free city of Rürenbourg had become engulfed in a most noxious heresy, whose adherents refer to themselves as the Restitvtores Ecclesiae Verae. He asked me for my help, in infiltrating the city and gathering information on the nature of Rürenbourg. Much of the content of this letter is based on notes I intended to give to the inquisitor, but events have intervened to prevent that. I am currently unaware of the man's whereabouts, and can only pray that he still lives.

I assumed the guise of a former villein, working as a scullery maid in Rürenburg, aspiring to stay in the city for a year and a day. I found the burghers to generally be a welcoming lot -- in fact, perhaps welcoming is not the right word, so much as eager to please. Many seemed mysteriously determined to prove their worthiness before a runaway serf. It took no inquiries to find myself inducted into their heretical church.

The perversion, spiritual and corporeal, that I found within the Sorores Christi (for so the most esteemed females of the heretics call themselves) has shaken me deeply.

Forgive me, Your Grace, if some of this letter seems lurid and impious in its content. What I write no doubt shocks the conscience, but I do so not for any ignominious purpose, but merely to report the truth. Once you are in full posession of the truth, it is not for one of my station to presume to tell you what you should do with it, but I have faith that you will reach a conclusion similar to my own: that the vile heresy must be crushed without mercy, its existence expunged from the annals of history, and, if the Lord in his infinite wisdom does not reveal some gentler path to us, the entire city of Rürenbourg must likewise be razed and all evidence of its existence expunged from the annals of history.

The theology of the Restitutors is based on twisted hermeneutics which turn the Holy Scriptures into the vilest blasphemy. They hold that the material world is a land of suffering and evil, created not by the true God, but by some diabolical being. This devil, they assert, is the one who spoke to the Jews, seeking power and domination over them for its own satisfaction. They claim that the Old Testament is filled with divine commands for horrible iniquities (such as Deuteronomy 22:28-29). The true God, they believe, appears in the Old Testament only as the serpent of Eden, partially undermining the devil's tyranny by granting Adam and Eve knowledge of Good and Evil.

They claim the Christ as a messenger from a greater God, just as the serpent was, coming once more to awaken the divinity in humankind and liberate us from the devil's bondage. Echoing the docetists of old, they deny entirely the human nature of the Christ, claiming that he was an entirely spiritual being.

The heretics distinguish between the Lex Ivdaeorvm, the wicked laws the devil sought to impose on his subjects, which they claim emanate from hatred, and the Lex Dei, the good laws brought forth by the true God and communicated to humanity by Christ, which they claim emanate from love. This doctrine has lead them to virtually destroy the Jews and Jewesses of Rürenbourg: for Jews are tantamount to diabolists under their doctrine, and they must renounce worship of the cruel false god or be destroyed. Thus has a third of Rürenbourg's Jewry converted to this heresy at swordpoint, a third fled the city in terror, and a third been slain after refusing to renounce their faith.

The heretics regard themselves as holding no loyalty to the material world, and profess allegiance only to the blessed spiritual world. They proclaim the equality of men and women, proclaim all believers to be priests, and deny any distinction between lords, vassals, and serfs. They abstain from meat, renounce marriage, and devise cruel methods of mortifying the hated flesh to exalt the spirit.

During my time in the Sorores Christi, I found a particular perversity in the womens' attempts to punish and agonize the flesh in their attempts purify their souls. That they abstained from any form of licit carnal pleasure goes without saying, for the heretics of Rürenbourg -- at least those devoted enough to acquire a place in the Fratres Christi or Sorores Christi -- do not marry. Yet they seek not a serene freedom from carnal desire, but rather a constant war with it. It is not enough for the soul to ignore the wants of the body. Rather, they seek to inflame their desires, only so that they may crush them. They stir perpetual rebellion within their bodies, so that they can perpetually triumph over them.

thoughts

Your exposition is extremely detailed about the ideas you wish to present in the story, but if the story itself follows the general flow of the exerpt you've got there, I'd expect something in the line of fantasy/historical fiction with a small side of T&D. If that's your aim, by all means go for it.
As far as the names & places are concerned, I figure after about 8 or 9 letter (tops), most people stop trying to read them. In the end you get lonely umlauts that find themselves skipped over by the bulk of the audience that finds itself more enjoying the plot than pausing to mentally pronounce some of the longer proper nouns. Perhaps something as simple as shortening them by a few letters, or making the names require a bit less time to sound out, unless you don't mind people simply looking at it as a name & forgetting it was ever in the text until the next time it appears. Nothing is lost in plot & content, though such readers might not be visualising the story as much.
The letter format works for this, though I wouldn't recommend using it constantly, or even often. If the story seems to be a correspondence between two people, it sounds more aloof & distant of the situation, thus it becomes less emotive & turns into a description of the story, rather than the fleshy details we've come to know & love.
As far as the fake medieval style is concerned, from what I've gathered here, you couldn't make it the same kind of story without that. Keep it.

I'm rambling now. Actually I was rambling about halfway through this, so I'll leave it at that & wish you luck with your story. The least I can say is I don't think I've ever seen anything like it before. It's new, innovative, & I hope to see a final product.
littlemoon's avatar

You've got me interested. I w

You've got me interested. I was not troubled by the language, though as a jew I have no more familiarity with catholic terminology than one would glean from The Davinci Code (and wonder if the bits about destruction of the jews is strictly necessary for the story).

But I enjoy this sort of outsider observation narrative told in letters. The novel "Aztec" is very similar to this and I thought it worked great. Have you read it? "The 13th Warrior" is another one.

I'm looking forward to the next chapter.

*lm*
nonsequitur's avatar

Great

It's nice that you are trying to be literary as well as erotic. I like it the way it is. Can't wait for more installments.

Story Concept

I too can't wait to read a final finished story. As far as your inclusion of what happens to the Jews in your story, sadly this is fact not fiction. There is a young adult book called The Cure. It begins as sci-fi but is actually historical fiction. It depicts what actually happened to many Jewish communities during the Black Death and the Inquisition. Keep it in - it roots your story in historical fact.

just an idea

Maybe she could be discovered and forced to endure public tease and denial over several weeks.

Outstanding concept!

I love it! Including the period language, it's excellent. For some reason historical settings really do it for me. Hope you write this up into a very long story.

My suggestion:
His grace the Archbishop decides it is critical to the work of God that the church infiltrate the inner circles of the Sorores Christi. And so he commands Hannah of Eslohe upon her holy vows, to do whatever is necessary to achieve exhaltation among the heretics. He assigns his most trusted and skilled inquisitor and his several female assistants to provide 'guidance and support' to her in this dangerous and trying endevour. She must take up the practices of the heretics, to the utmost. She must involve herself in all their ceremonies and routines. In addition, she must every day provide demonstrations of her prescribed practices in their entirety, under the supervision of the inquisitor and assistants in his trust. This is necessary to construct a detailed written chronicle of the heretics perversions. Due to the great threat the heretics present to the church, and the urgency of the situation, she MUST NOT falter, she must exceed and excell in their ungodly expectations. She must be genuine and exemplary in her unceasing mortification of her carnality, even to the risk of her mind, though her soul be sanctified by her sacrifice. She has his dispensation that she may put aside those parts of her vows forbidding such unchaste practices, but only upon the understanding that she does not at any time permit or bring by her own actions the carnal release. That remains a mortal sin, for which she would be excommunicated, as well as severely punished in this world for her lapse. The only exceptions allowed will be at the discretion of the inquisitor, should he judge such release to be beneficial to her assignment.

His grace understands the difficulties in this task, especially for her in light of the incidents recorded during her novitiate years. He commends her for the determination and piety she had eventually developed, despite the handicap of her unusually prominent womanly parts. He was pleased to receive the church physician report that those parts exhibited a rare but entirely corporeal propensity for spontaneous and prolonged excitation, and that initial fears among her superiors she may have been possessed of the devil were unfounded. He is informed by her order that she still struggles with this affliction. He assures her that her tribulations are revealed to ultimately be in service of God's purpose, for now her particular condition shall serve well for the investigation of the unholy heretics.
Understanding that the task itself is arduous, and especially so for her, he instructs his inquisitor to apply all his arts and vigilance to ensure that she does not fail in this great duty to the Church. The inquisitor will arrange for others to infiltrate the heretics to provide her with constant attendance and assistance in her difficult path. She will not know them, but they will know her.

Notes
Naturally his grace will participate in disguise, as one of the inquisitor's assistants. Just to keep an eye on things, of course! Also note that whatever Hannah has to do daily for the Order, she'll end up doing *twice* per day due to having to provide demonstrations to the inquisitor. And during those, she'll have to watch some of the inquisitor's assistants having lots of orgasms themselves, as they watch and help 'mortify Hannah's carnal desires'.

Also, the inquisitor would consider it useful to subject Hannah to many days of intensive familiarization with the numerous manners in which her carnality and it's release may overcome her. He and his agents must observe this, the better to ensure she will impress the heretics with her zeal in approaching to infinitessimal distance but not allowing the release once her mission begins in earnest. He also feels that sharpening the desires of her flesh by habituation of those needs will serve her well in the future task.

Damn! I'm making myself want to write the story! But as you can see, I don't have command of the necessay period phrasing and vocabulary. Which you do so well.

How's it going?
jecarv's avatar

General note: I think that "r

General note: I think that "restitvtores ecclesiae verae" isn't a very good name for a heretical sect. It's what they'd call themselves, perhaps, at least on their official stationary (er... vellum, or whatever), but probably not what anyone else would call them. I think they need a catchier name -- maybe the Rürenbourgenses? Or maybe shorten it to Rürenenses?

Re: SensoryOverlord, I've currently been busy with a few other things lately (like getting moved out of my old apartment), but I might want to take a crack. Anyone, those are some neat ideas -- if you feel inspired to write something along the lines of my idea, then feel free to do so.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click 'Save settings' to activate your changes.